Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

Explore Our Properties
44 St Marys Road
Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate, Michael Brennan Listing Contact: 631-725-0200 
Sold

44 St Marys Road

44 St Marys Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964

$3,500,000
Limited opportunity for this special property! Unique Shelter Island opportunity to find 8.5 acres with unobstructed scenic views that will leave you speechless. This classic property is currently being utilized as a horse farm, with a 3 bedroom main house, 3 stall horse stables, a barn and a pool house/garage with studio and full bath above. The main house features 3 en-suite bedrooms, kitchen, living room, dining room, a den/sunroom off the primary suite and a large mudroom with laundry. The second floor features two large en-suite bedrooms and a bonus room. With all this land, this is a great opportunity to reimagine the current home or to bring your architect and create your own dream. Located in "C Residential" zone, the possibilities are endless, with subdivision opportunities and full development rights. This property and all of its surrounding land promise a lifestyle of unparalleled beauty, adventure, and tranquility., Additional information: Interior Features:Guest Quarters

3
beds

4
baths

3,225 Sq.Ft. LIVING AREA

8.45 Acres lot

Features & Amenities

Interior

  • total bedrooms3
  • Total bathrooms4
  • full bathrooms4
  • Flooring Hardwood
  • APPLIANCES Cooktop, Dishwasher, Dryer, Oven, Refrigerator, Washer, Oil Water Heater
  • other interior Features Formal Dining, Master Downstairs, Primary Bathroom, Pantry, Walk-In Closet(s)

Area & Lot

  • Status Sold
  • Date Sold February 11, 2025
  • Living Area3,225 Sq.Ft.
  • Lot Area8.45 Acres
  • MLS® IDL3560589
  • TypeResidential
  • YEAR BUILT1985
  • Architecture StylesFarm House
  • View DescriptionPanoramic
  • Middle SchoolShelter Island School
  • High SchoolShelter Island School
  • School DistrictShelter Island

Exterior

  • water SourceDrilled Well
  • PoolIn Ground
  • lot featuresPart Wooded
  • parkingDetached, Private
  • HEAT TYPEForced Air, Propane
  • AIR CONDITIONINGCentral Air, Wall Unit(s)
  • sewerSeptic Tank
  • HOA AmenitiesFitness Center
  • security FeaturesSecurity System

Financial

  • Sales Price$3,500,000
  • Real Estate Tax $11,587/yr

Considering Your Next Move?

Whether you’re preparing to sell, considering your options, or planning ahead, we provide thoughtful guidance and a clear strategy to help you move forward with confidence.

Follow Us on Instagram